Welcome back to Week 51 in my weekly reports analyzing the Covid-19 pandemic and its effects on the country and higher education in the Biden-Harris administration, and Happy Easter to all. For those of you reading this on my blog, Off the Silk Road, I have also launched a newsletter, where these reports can be sent directly to your email each week. Click here to subscribe.
Last week, we examined the beginnings of a possible fourth surge as more vaccines were distributed. This week, we will continue to focus on the split screen pandemic as it is shown through vaccines and variants.
A national look
“I’m going to pause here. I’m going to lose the script. And I’m going to reflect on the recurring feeling I have of impending doom. We have so much to look forward to, so much promise and potential of where we are, and so much reason for hope, but right now I’m scared.”
These were words spoken by CDC Director Dr. Rochelle Walensky at Monday’s White House Covid-19 press briefing. The evidence is clear: We are in a race between vaccines and variants, and in some places, the variants are winning. Surges in Michigan, the Northeast and Florida have driven case counts to increase, especially in largely unvaccinated young people. Emergency rooms are filling up again, all with unvaccinated patients. In New York City, data show that variants make up 72% of cases. Although this new surge may be hitting the U.S. evenly due to universal variants, differences in vaccination rates have led to heterogeneity in case counts.
Last year around this time, the former president said that this country would be up and running by Easter. When we think about the latest trends, it feels like Groundhog Day all over again. This will realistically be the last holiday for which Americans will need to stay home/gather in incredibly small groups. After all we have lost over the last year, we are counting on everyone to ensure we minimize fatalities over the next few weeks.
In Florida, cases have already started to increase among young people from ages 15 to 34.
In Michigan, Covid-19 cases (black lines) are rising in younger demographics, many of whom have not been vaccinated (blue lines). Cases in the older age bands are flatlining due to a slow vaccine rollout.
Last Sunday, CNN premiered an incredible documentary by Dr. Sanjay Gupta entitled “Covid War,” which unpacked the U.S.’ Covid-19 missteps and lessons learned with the nation’s top doctors leading the initial response. You can see a summary in this Twitter thread here. Dr. Gupta excelled in dissecting every misstep of our pandemic preparedness and response in chronological order, pressing these officials on what they knew, when they knew it and the decisions they made as a result. History will remember those who were complicit, those who did not speak the truth and hid behind the curtain while hundreds of thousands of Americans perished.
Let’s take a look at some of the latest scientific developments:
- The CDC updated its guidance for fully vaccinated people. While the agency discourages travel given the current conditions, fully vaccinated people should still wear a mask on planes and trains but do not need to get tested or quarantine.
- According to new data from researchers at Arizona State University, the B.1.243.1 variant is in the process of taking hold in Arizona and beginning to cross state borders to New Mexico and Texas. This variant contains the E484K mutation which allows escape from antibodies. More research is needed.
- When variants of SARS-CoV-2 emerged in late 2020, concern arose that they might elude protective immune responses generated by prior infection or vaccination, potentially making re-infection more likely or vaccination less effective. To investigate this possibility, researchers from the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID), part of the National Institutes of Health, and colleagues analyzed blood cell samples from 30 people who had contracted and recovered from Covid-19 prior to the emergence of virus variants. They found that one key player in the immune response to SARS-CoV-2—the CD8+ T cell—remained active against the virus.
- CDC data show that daily Covid-19 tests in the U.S. are declining. As vaccinations continue to ramp up and Covid-19 outbreaks become more isolated, we need to continue using testing as an important tool to track the spread of the virus and collect data.
- Four independent analyses have confirmed that the B.1.1.7 variant has on average a 60% increased mortality rate.
- The FDA cleared a number of at-home tests for use on the market, a major step to easy and frequent testing.
- The CDC, in collaboration with the National Institutes of Health (NIH), has launched an innovative community health initiative called “Say Yes! COVID Test” starting in Pitt County, North Carolina, and coming soon to Chattanooga/Hamilton County, Tennessee. As many as 160,000 residents across the two communities will have access to free, rapid antigen tests that they can administer themselves to use three times a week for one month.
- According to CDC data, Covid-19 was the third leading cause of death in 2020. Data published in JAMA showed that between March 1, 2020, and January 2, 2021, the U.S. experienced 2,801,439 deaths, 22.9% more than expected, representing 522,368 excess deaths.
- More than one in five healthcare workers (21%) have at least moderately considered leaving the workforce and 30% have considered reducing hours because of Covid-19 stress, according to a study in JAMA Network Open.
- Research from Alyssa Bilinski and colleagues indicated strong correspondence between rising Covid-19 case reports and increases in individual risk perceptions and mitigating behaviors. Nevertheless, the temporal coincidence between surging cases and behavior changes suggests that this reactive dynamic is likely too late to prevent substantial outbreaks and associated morbidity and mortality. However, with good information about the changing public health situation, people are usually quite swift at reacting through changes in their behavior.
- A commentary in JAMA found that on-premises restaurant dining has been associated with increases in daily Covid-19 case growth rates 41-100 days after implementation and increases in daily death growth rates 61-100 days after implementation.
Yesterday, the U.S. reported a record of 4.08 million doses administered, with the 7-day average now at 3.07 million shots per day. Over 100 million Americans have had at least one dose. This is an historic accomplishment. In 21 states, vaccinations are now open to anyone over the age of 16. All states have announced dates to open vaccine eligibility for all adults, with 93.5% of the American adult population scheduled to be eligible by April 19. This is in line with President Biden’s new 90/90 plan — 90% of adults eligible by May 1, and 90% of Americans within 5 miles of a vaccination site.
The latest polling data show that vaccine hesitancy is declining in much of the U.S. From a Kaiser Family Foundation survey, the overall percentage of those unwilling to receive a vaccine has remained constant but the number of those in the “wait and see” group have declined. One of the most interesting findings is that among the “wait and see” group, significantly more people would want to get the Johnson & Johnson vaccine due to its one-dose nature.
However, the country is obviously not one heterogeneous entity, and in the coming weeks we will be seeing two factors at play: limited vaccine delivery infrastructure and signs of vaccine hesitancy. As seen here, Massachusetts has two steady curves of vaccines distributed and administered. However, Mississippi’s gap has widened. This may point to issues accessing vaccines, or probably more likely vaccine hesitancy. The doses are there and no one is there to take them. This week, the White House said it has not made a decision to possibly change allocations based on demand.
On the other side of the world, impressive results from Israel’s vaccination campaign continue. As of a week ago, the latest Health Ministry data showed 56.1% of the population has received their second dose. Herd immunity is not a binary — once more people are vaccinated, cases decline.
As we head into April, supply will no longer be a constraint. Data from the manufacturers (Pfizer, Moderna and Johnson & Johnson) show that all three met their supply targets for the end of March.
We still have a long way to go when it comes to ensuring vaccine equity. Hispanic people across the United States, for example continue to be especially underrepresented among those vaccinated for Covid-19, according to a New York Times analysis of state-reported race and ethnicity information.
A few other updates on vaccines:
- This week, a significant CDC report was published on the effectiveness of the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines in frontline workers. The data showed the vaccines were 80% effective 14 days after the 1st dose (regardless of symptoms) and 90% effective against infection 2 days after the 2nd dose. The CDC report is significant, experts said, because it analyzed how well the vaccines worked among a diverse group of front-line working-age adults whose jobs make them more likely to be exposed to the virus and to spread it. Without vaccination, you would expect to see 162 infections among 1,000 people. With full vaccination, you would see 1 infection among 1,000 people.
- Results from Pfizer’s clinical trial found no symptomatic infections among vaccinated children ages 12 to 15 and there were no serious side effects. This is a major step in vaccinating high school kids before school in the fall.
- As Politico’s Erin Banco reports, the Biden administration is making profound changes in its vaccination strategy, shifting much of the focus away from large mass vaccination sites to smaller community-based pharmacies and other sites. This is not entirely unexpected. The data show that the federally-run vaccination sites gave on average 67,000 shots per day, 2.5% of all doses administered nationwide. By comparison, the federal retail pharmacy program reported on March 11 that it had administered nearly 1 million doses over a single day.
- With every state opening up vaccines to all adults in the coming weeks, we need to ensure that the delivery, trust and equity systems are in place. A new op-ed from Drs. Rebecca Weintraub, Julie Rosenberg and Eric Goralnick lays out five steps states should take.
- Nationwide, most of the elderly and vulnerable in long-term care facilities have taken the coronavirus vaccine, but many of the staff caring for them have refused it. Around 50% of long-term care workers have not been vaccinated, according to reporting from the Center for Public Integrity.
- Workers at a Baltimore plant manufacturing two coronavirus vaccines accidentally conflated the vaccines’ ingredients several weeks ago, ruining about 15 million doses of Johnson & Johnson’s vaccine and forcing regulators to delay authorization of the plant’s production lines.
- The Biden administration is creating a network of outside health experts and community leaders charged with building trust in coronavirus vaccines called the Covid-19 Community Corps. For more information and to sign up, see here.
- The FDA authorized Moderna’s request to increase doses in each vial from 10 to 15, dramatically augmenting the vaccine supply in the coming weeks.
- The ongoing Phase 3 clinical trial of Pfizer/BioNTech’s coronavirus vaccine confirms its protection remains high for at least six months after the second dose. The vaccine remains more than 91% effective against disease with any symptoms for six months, the companies stated. And it appeared to be fully effective against the worrying B.1.351 variant of the virus, which is the dominant strain circulating in South Africa and which researchers feared had evolved to evade the protection of vaccines. Pfizer will aim to seek for full FDA approval soon.
- Vaccinating kids will be an important step in ending this pandemic, as Dr. Angela Rasmussen and Dr. Jeremy Faust write. We have compiled the most comprehensive list yet of pediatric vaccine trials. Most will not report efficacy against severe disease and will focus on safety and immune response instead, as kids are already less susceptible to severe disease.
- The White House is looking to governors to boost confidence in the Johnson & Johnson coronavirus vaccine as the company ramps up supply in the U.S, and many have done so already. Whether it is due to supply or uptake, we are still seeing low usage rates.
- Johnson & Johnson became the third company to enter the race to expand the use of its coronavirus vaccine to adolescents.
- With Florida Governor Ron DeSantis issuing an executive order banning “vaccine passports,” they are now set to be the next front in the pandemic culture wars.
- Data published in The Lancet showed the AstraZeneca vaccine was 70% effective against symptomatic Covid-19 with the B.1.1.7 variant and 82% effective against non-B.1.1.7 cases.
- An Axios-Ipsos poll showed a strong correlation between the people who are influenced by Covid-19 vaccine misinformation and those who are unlikely to get the vaccine.
And one final note of levity, for those Survivor fans out there:
when more vaccination appointments are added pic.twitter.com/3xxIovNa3S— gabe bergado (@gabebergado) April 2, 2021
Let’s move on to our discussion of higher education.
As college students in many states are undergoing the process of being vaccinated, we have yet to see the effects of spring break trips. At Boston University, cases are already on the rise. At Bates College, students are confined to their rooms due to an outbreak. The University of Michigan has yet another rise in cases. Data from Davidson College’s College Crisis Initiative found that 26.3 % of surveyed institutions had no break scheduled, while 40.8% had a regular spring break scheduled. Interestingly, 32.8% of institutions had some “other” type of spring break.
In many areas, college student vaccinations have already begun. Ohio and Connecticut have announced statewide plans to vaccinate college students with the Johnson & Johnson vaccine. At Notre Dame, the school will hold clinics for students to receive the Pfizer vaccine. The City of Philadelphia has approved the University of Pennsylvania as an official Covid-19 vaccination site, paving the way for Penn community members to receive vaccines on campus in the coming weeks. Some schools in New Hampshire have announced plans to hold vaccination clinics, with out-of-state students left out due to the governor’s orders.
The ethics of prioritizing college students for vaccines remain divided. “If college students are going to take shots in bars during spring break, it’s time we make sure they have shots in their arms. Students need to jump to the front of the line for Covid-19 vaccinations even if they don’t fall into high-risk groups,” Davidson College professor Chris Marsicano writes. “Doing so will make them and the communities they visit safer — and allow colleges and universities to reopen for the fall to avoid disrupting more educations and local economies.” However, in many states, the most vulnerable have still not received the chance to be vaccinated. “Once we have more vaccine available, which should be very soon, it’s reasonable to vaccinate college students, especially ones who are returning to multigenerational families, and colleges should certainly do this,” David Michaels, a professor at George Washington University’s school of public health who served on the Biden administration’s Covid-19 advisory board during the presidential transition, said to The Chronicle of Higher Education’s Francie Diep. “But right now, I’d like to see the states focused on older people, people with comorbidities, and essential workers.” It will be a race against the clock, with a push to ensure students do not receive a second dose in the middle of final exams, given possible side effects.
In other higher ed news this week, NPR’s Elissa Nadworny reported on custodians cleaning the University of Florida in the middle of a pandemic and the Chronicle’s Karin Fischer documented a year without study abroad.
The Good Stuff
Let’s roll the clips of the good stuff. In my usual tradition, I feature my favorite stories from the week. Here are my Top 10.
- The Ever Given, the ship stuck in the Suez Canal, is finally free! The Egyptian dredging team celebrated and CNN created an interactive where you can try your luck at steering the ship.
- Over the coming months, Americans will be returning to offices, traveling, and eating cheeseburgers inside sports bars, The Atlantic’s Ian Bogost writes. But the vaccines’ arrival has also provided a more immediate relief: giving people something to talk about.
- For April Fool’s, Vermont news site VTDigger turned into VTDogger, with your favorite canine related headlines.
- For the first time, women hold the highest editorial positions at all eight Ivy League college papers.
- The Associated Press took an inside look at the White House Covid-19 briefings in the Biden era.
- Congratulations to the winners and all the nominees of the Data Hero Awards! Rebekah Jones did an excellent job at compiling and shining light on all the accomplishments of these individuals, who have worked for over a year to bring you data on the pandemic.
- The creator of TurboVax, Huge Ma helped thousands of New Yorkers get vaccinated. Now he’s using his platform to combat anti-Asian racism.
- The Atlantic’s Derek Thompson took down, one-by-one, the false claims frequent Fox News guest Alex Berenson made throughout the pandemic.
- NPR published an interactive memorial to some of the victims of Covid-19.
- Dolly Parton has received her second dose of the Moderna vaccine.
Dolly gets a (second) dose of her own medicine.— Dolly Parton (@DollyParton) April 2, 2021
Thank you Dr. Naji Abumrad, Andrea Calhoun and Heather O’Dell of @VUMChealth ❤️ pic.twitter.com/IDez2DnkzX
The summer prognosis continues to look excellent, and with each week’s data we become more encouraged with the abilities of these vaccines. Families have been able to reunite with those in long-term care facilities as visitation policies are relaxed. However, we need to continue to promote equity and vaccinate the most vulnerable. This will help reduce mortality. Young people are continuing to drive this surge of cases nationally, and we need to do all we can to ensure they are able to avoid illness before they get vaccinated as well, which is only in a number of weeks. While vaccinations will win in the end, these next few weeks will test Americans for one final time.
I’d like to thank all the student journalists with whom I have the pleasure of working. In the next weeks and months ahead, they will become vital in chronicling their colleges’ paths forward for the spring and beyond. Support their work by reading it.
My best to all for good health.
Like what you see? Don’t like what you see? Want to see more of something? Want to see less of something? Let me know in the comments. And don’t forget to subscribe to the weekly newsletter!
For more instant updates, follow me on Twitter @bhrenton.